How it works

How an unlicensed insurance broker used applications she controlled to leave more than 500 drivers uninsured

Tampa, Florida, United States · scheme ran February 2017 to August 2023; US Attorney's Office for the Middle District of Florida, press release, 6 November 2026

Scam Watch · 7 November 2026

An isometric path of tiles from a small blue car, through a laptop with a blank form, an envelope passed between two hands and a document with a red cross, back to the car.

Katrenia Harris, 55, of Tampa, has been sentenced to 13 months in federal prison for wire fraud, the US Attorney's Office for the Middle District of Florida announced on 6 November 2026. She pleaded guilty on 16 April 2026 and must forfeit $49,772.40, the proceeds of the fraud. Prosecutors say she defrauded more than 500 people. This is how the scheme worked, according to court documents:

  1. From about February 2017 to August 2023, she presented herself as a licensed insurance broker offering car insurance. She was not licensed and not an authorised broker.
  2. She submitted applications online or by phone using each customer's real name, but with email addresses and phone numbers that only she controlled.
  3. Because of that, the first proof of insurance went to her accounts, not to the customer.
  4. She forwarded the proof to the customer. She did not pay the required premiums.
  5. The policies were cancelled shortly after they began. She did not tell the customers.
  6. They kept driving without valid insurance, and claims for losses went unpaid.
Where you can still stop it
  • Step 1: before you pay a broker, ask for their licence number and check it with your state's insurance regulator.
  • Step 2: the email address and phone number on your application should be yours. Ask to see the application.
  • Step 3: get the insurer's name and your policy number, then log in on the insurer's own website or call it on the number you find yourself.
  • Step 5: a few days after you buy, check with the insurer that the policy is still active. If it is not, tell your state insurance regulator.

Source: US Attorney's Office for the Middle District of Florida, press release, 6 November 2026
Read the original: justice.gov