How it works

How a US letter carrier's stolen checks were rewritten and cashed through strangers' bank accounts

Indianapolis, Indiana, United States · scheme ran April 2020 to May 2022; US Attorney's Office for the Southern District of Indiana, press release, 4 November 2026

Scam Watch · 6 November 2026

An isometric path of tiles from a street mailbox, through an envelope, a pen over a blank cheque, a bank card and a cash machine, to a pile of coins.

A former US Postal Service letter carrier in Indianapolis, Destinee Ruffin, 29, has been sentenced to six and a half years in federal prison for conspiracy to commit bank fraud and theft of mail, federal prosecutors in Indiana said on Wednesday 4 November 2026. Prosecutors estimate about 6,500 people were affected. This is how the scheme worked, according to court documents:

  1. From April 2020 to May 2022, Ruffin used her access to incoming and outgoing mail at the Bacon Station post office to steal checks and sell them to co-conspirators.
  2. One buyer, Tony McMullen, paid her through Cash App: in one example, 38 payments totalling over $10,000. Another, John Young, got more than $12 million in stolen checks from her and listed many of them for sale on Telegram.
  3. McMullen looked on social media for people willing to deposit altered checks into their own bank accounts. They handed over debit cards, PINs or online banking logins.
  4. He changed the payee on the stolen checks, deposited them, then took the money out or demanded payment through Cash App or Zelle. He cashed 36 checks worth about $235,632 this way.
  5. The people who mailed the checks learned late. One woman's $1,618 check for her retired husband's health insurance never arrived; she found out when she arrived for a scheduled surgery, was told her insurance had been terminated, and the operation was cancelled.

A search in April 2024 found thousands more stolen checks, worth over $20 million, that she had not yet sold.

Where you can still stop it
  • Step 1: a check in the mail can be taken on the way. For regular bills, ask whether you can pay electronically instead.
  • Step 3: if someone online offers you money to deposit a check or lend them your bank card and PIN, say no. Accounts like that are how these checks were cashed.
  • Step 5: after you mail a check, look at your account to see when it is cashed and by whom. If the payee says nothing arrived, tell your bank at once.
  • If a check you mailed went missing, report the mail theft to the US Postal Inspection Service as well as your bank.

Source: US Attorney's Office for the Southern District of Indiana, press release, 4 November 2026
Read the original: justice.gov